top of page

As a Former Dealer, I Don't Like What I'm Seeing.

 

As a former automotive dealer, I've spent enough years in this business to know how these stories usually end.

The people making the decisions rarely assume the risks.

The people assuming the risks rarely get asked for their opinions.

Today we're being told that Chinese electric vehicles entering Canada are good for consumers, good for competition and good for the future.

Maybe.

But from where I sit, that's only half the story.

The other half is what happens to the dealers, manufacturers, suppliers, technicians and workers who spent decades building Canada's automotive industry while politicians and industry experts chase the latest trend.

I'm not questioning whether Chinese EVs are good vehicles. Many of them are.

What I'm questioning is whether Canada is inviting in a wave of competition that could undermine the very industry that has supported hundreds of thousands of Canadian jobs for generations.

And frankly, I don't think enough people are asking hard questions.

 

I've Seen Dealers Burned Before

One thing I learned during my years as a dealer is that manufacturers make promises when they want market share.

Then circumstances change.

Strategies change.

Executives change.

And suddenly the dealer who invested millions based on those promises is left trying to figure out what happened.

Now we're seeing Chinese manufacturers looking at Canada as a growth opportunity.

My question is simple.

Who's taking the risk?

Because it certainly won't be the politicians making announcements or the consultants writing reports.

It will be the dealer investing millions in facilities, inventory, training, equipment and staffing.

It always is.

 

This Isn't Free-Market Competition

Let's stop pretending this is some kind of level playing field.

Canadian businesses operate under one set of costs.

Chinese manufacturers operate under another.

Different labour structures.

Different government involvement.

Different economic realities.

When someone points to a Chinese EV selling for thousands less than a North American competitor, my response is simple.

That's not the whole story.

The real story is what happens to Canadian businesses forced to compete against companies that don't play by the same rules.

 

What Happens When They Leave?

Nobody talks much about this part.

Everyone gets excited when a new brand arrives.

Far fewer people talk about what happens if that brand fails.

What happens if they pull out of Canada?

What happens if the parts network dries up?

What happens if warranty support becomes difficult?

What happens if Canadian sales don't meet expectations and head office decides to focus elsewhere?

Customers won't call government ministers.

They're going to call the dealer.

And the dealer will once again be left cleaning up somebody else's mess.

 

Canadian Jobs Aren't Disposable

What bothers me most is how casually some people discuss the potential impact on Canadian jobs.

It's almost as if manufacturing, suppliers and dealerships are viewed as obstacles rather than assets.

Every vehicle assembled in North America supports families.

Every supplier contract matters.

Every dealership employs people in sales, service, parts, administration and management.

When those jobs disappear, they don't magically come back.

Yet we're supposed to celebrate policies that could put additional pressure on an industry that's already navigating electrification mandates, economic uncertainty and changing consumer demand.

That seems backwards to me.

 

The Question Nobody Wants To Ask

The question isn't whether Chinese EVs can succeed in Canada.

The question is what happens if they do.

What happens to existing manufacturers?

What happens to dealership values?

What happens to Canadian assembly plants?

What happens to suppliers?

What happens to thousands of small and medium-sized businesses connected to the automotive sector?

Nobody seems eager to have that conversation.

 

My View

As a former dealer, I've learned to be skeptical whenever someone says, "Don't worry, it'll all work out."

That's usually right before somebody loses money.

The vehicles may be good.

The technology may be impressive.

The prices may attract consumers.

But none of that answers the bigger question.

Are we strengthening Canada's automotive industry, or are we helping dismantle it one import at a time?

Because if we get this wrong, the damage won't be suffered by bureaucrats, lobbyists or policy makers.

It will be suffered by the people who invested their lives, their capital and their futures in an industry that helped build this country.

And that's a conversation worth having before it's too late.

 

— Tom McKenzie

bottom of page